Delving into Drew Estate Blackened S84 Shade to Black & M81

Delving into Drew Estate Blackened S84 Shade to Black & M81

Posted by Ana Cuenca on Apr 21, 2024

In the world of premium cigars, the Drew Estate Blackened S84 Shade to Black has ignited interest like a classic riff. If you’re craving details on its construction, taste, and the unique collaboration that brought it to fruition, you’re in the right place. This review gives you an insider’s look at why this cigar might just deserve a spot in your humidor.

Overview of Featured Cigars

Among Blackened cigars, two stand out as marvels of flavor and craftsmanship. Best for the connoisseur of smoothness: the Drew Estate Blackened S84, with its smooth wrapper and nuanced profile, reminiscent of a strong espresso. Best for the aficionado of boldness: the Blackened M81, a robust cigar that boasts a dark chocolaty core.

Together, they offer a comprehensive experience of maduro tobaccos, encapsulating the spirit of Nicaragua and the heritage of a musical icon.

In-depth Review of Drew Estate Blackened S84 Shade to Black

Illustration of blackened cigars

Price: [Insert price] Specifications:

  • Wrapper: Connecticut Ecuador
  • Binder: Connecticut River Valley Broadleaf Maduro
  • Filler: Nicaraguan Maduro and Pennsylvania Broadleaf Maduro
  • Sizes: Robusto, Toro, and more Pros:
  • Exquisite construction
  • Balanced flavor profile
  • Prestigious collaboration Cons:
  • Premium pricing
  • Limited edition availability

Igniting the Blackened S84 Shade to Black, anticipation hung heavy in the air. The first draws were like the opening chords of a Metallica ballad—smooth yet powerful, revealing a robust and chocolaty core that danced harmoniously with subtler notes of hay and white pepper. The craftsmanship was evident from the even burn to the firm ash, a testament to the skill of master distiller Rob Dietrich and the artistic vision of Jonathan Drew. The blackened s84 shade was not just a cigar; it was a narrative of luxury, a follow-up to a legend.

Rating: Taste: 9.3/10 Construction: 9.5/10 Value: 8.8/10 Experience: 9.3/10

Unveiling the Blackened M81

Illustration of Metallica's James Hetfield

Price: $9.15 - $10.35 per unit


  • Wrapper: Mexican San Andrés Maduro
  • Binder: Connecticut River Valley Broadleaf
  • Filler: Nicaraguan and Pennsylvania Green River One Sucker Tobaccos
  • Sizes: Corona Doble, Toro, Robusto, and Corona


  • Rich and full-flavored profile
  • Exceptional price-to-quality ratio
  • Notable collaboration with Metallica’s James Hetfield


  • May be too bold for beginners
  • Specific taste may not suit all preferences

With the first light of the Blackened M81, earthy and black pepper notes filled the air, each puff revealing a deep chocolaty core. The black robusto size, a canvas measuring 5 inches with a 50 ring gauge, was a door to boldness, its dark brown, oily wrapper hinting at the unapologetic full-bodied character within. A collaboration over a decade in the making, this cigar was not only a tribute to Metallica but also a declaration of the whiskey-induced passion that Rob Dietrich and co-founder Jonathan Drew share for blending traditions and innovation.

Rating: Flavor: 9.4/10 Strength: 9/10 Affordability: 9.2/10 Overall Experience: 9.3/10

Comparing the S84 and M81

Although the S84 Shade to Black and the M81 are both part of the Blackened family, they offer distinct experiences. The S84, crowned with an Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper, offers a smooth and nuanced smoking experience, a serenade of finesse and composure. In contrast, the M81’s Maduro wrapper delivers a bold and earthy symphony, a crescendo of full-bodied strength. Both share the foundational qualities of a Connecticut Broadleaf binder and a blend of Nicaraguan Maduro and Pennsylvania Broadleaf Maduro fillers, yet they diverge in their stories—the S84 Shade to black is a nod to Metallica’s 1984 album, while the M81 resonates with the spirit of the band’s legacy and the robustness of blackened whiskey.

When selecting between the S84 Shade to Black and the M81, consider the occasion, your taste preference, and the desired strength. If a smooth, medium-bodied experience with a complex yet accessible profile suits your palate, the S84 is your stage. For those seeking a cigar with a stronger, more pronounced flavor narrative that echoes the depth of whiskey and the richness of Metallica’s music heritage, the M81 opens the door. Each cigar is a journey, one of subtlety, the other of intensity, both leading to a memorable finale.

Decoding Cigar Terminology

The realm of blackened cigars is filled with specific jargon that shapes the experience. The wrapper, a cigar’s outer leaf, is the maestro conducting the taste and burn evenness with its aesthetic and structural grace. It’s the first impression, the handshake before the deeper conversation of flavor, and the S84 Shade to Black’s Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper is a masterclass in smooth introductions.

Meanwhile, the binder acts as the backbone, a leaf of steadfast quality that secures the filler in place. It’s the rhythm section that influences the draw’s tightness and burn rate—critical elements for an even performance.

Fillers are the soul of the cigar, a blend of leaves like the Nicaraguan Maduro and Pennsylvania Broadleaf Maduro that establish the cigar’s flavor narrative, strength, and boldness. The strength, dictated by nicotine levels, ranges from light to full-bodied, akin to a music genre spectrum where each smoker finds their preferred beat.

For beginners, starting with lighter maduro tobaccos is akin to easing into a new album, allowing the nuances to reveal themselves without overwhelming the senses.

Choosing the Right Cigar for You

Illustration of a smooth cigar and whiskey

Choosing a cigar is as individual as picking a fine whiskey or favorite tune. It’s about finding harmony between your preferences and the cigar’s character. Begin by considering the aromas and flavors that resonate with you. Do you seek the smooth, chocolaty notes of a Nicaraguan Maduro, or the bold, earthy tones of a blackened cigar? Keeping a record of your experiences, noting the cigars that struck a chord, will fine-tune your preferences over time.

Consider your experience level. If you’re new to the cigar world, a lighter or medium-bodied cigar like the Blackened S84 Shade will introduce you to the symphony without overpowering your senses. However, if you’re a seasoned smoker, the full-bodied richness of the M81 may be more your tempo. The time you have to indulge in your cigar also plays a role. A robusto size may be perfect for a leisurely interlude, while a longer smoke requires a larger format and more time to appreciate.

Pricing is another verse in this song. While the Blackened S84 Shade to Black might be priced at a premium, it’s a testament to quality and the unique collaboration behind it. Budget considerations are valid, and thankfully, the cigar world offers a range of options to suit various financial scores. Whether it’s a special occasion or a casual retreat to your smoking sanctuary, the right cigar awaits to complement the moment.

How to Properly Store and Maintain Your Cigars

Similar to aged whiskey or a vinyl record, a cigar also requires careful maintenance to preserve its quality. To ensure that your blackened cigars retain their foundational qualities and maduro tobaccos’ rich flavors, store them at temperatures below 73°F (23°C) and at humidity levels between 68-74%. This delicate balance prevents the harsh taste and wrapper damage that can mar the smoking experience. The ideal storage conditions are a consistent 70°F (21°C) and 70% humidity, a sanctuary where the cigar’s quality can be preserved.

A humidor is the chosen dwelling for your cigars, a haven that should be selected for its capacity to cradle your collection and its ability to maintain consistent humidity levels. Equipped with a hygrometer to measure humidity and a humidifier to control it, a well-calibrated humidor is the guardian of your cigars. Regularly monitoring and adjusting the humidity every two weeks ensures that your cigars are always ready to perform at their best.

Avoid storing cigars in the refrigerator or considering freezing, as these environments can desiccate and damage them. Instead, select a cool, dry place shielded from direct sunlight to prevent mold and beetles from compromising your collection. With proper maintenance, your cigars will be like cherished memories, always ready to be revisited and savored.


As the final notes of this exploration fade, we reflect on the rich profiles of the Drew Estate Blackened S84 Shade to Black and the M81, each a unique expression of craftsmanship and heritage. We’ve decoded the terminology, guided you through selecting the right cigar for your palate, and shared the secrets to preserving your precious collection. Now, armed with knowledge and inspired by the legacies behind these cigars, you stand ready to embark on your own journey through the aromatic landscapes of maduro tobaccos and blackened cigars.

What differentiates the wrapper of the S84 Shade to Black from other cigars?

The S84 Shade to Black's smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut. Shade to black wrapper sets it apart from other cigars, offering a nuanced smoking experience and an elegant appearance.

How long can I expect to enjoy the Drew Estate Blackened S84 Shade to Black?

You can expect to enjoy the Drew Estate Blackened S84 Shade to Black for approximately 49 minutes, providing a satisfying session of rich flavor notes and quality construction.

What are the distinctive flavor notes of the Blackened M81?

The distinctive flavor notes of the Blackened M81 include earthiness, black pepper, and dark chocolate, offering a medium to full strength experience.

How should I store my Blackened cigars to maintain their quality?

To maintain the quality of your Blackened cigars, store them at temperatures below 73°F and humidity levels between 68-74%. This will preserve their flavor and prevent damage.

Can I store cigars in the refrigerator to keep them fresh?

No, storing cigars in the refrigerator can dry them out. It's best to use a humidor with the proper humidity levels to keep them fresh.